There's a lot of speculation about what the changes will be for the upcoming (imminent?) release of Warhammer's 9th edition. I've been trying to find the time (and work up the motivation) to write a lengthy post about what I'd like to see "fixed" in the new rulebook. I've heard opinions ranging from "6th is the best edition ever," to "8th is the best ever," and there are some people who think 8th edition is completely broken to the point of being unplayable.
I've been playing Warhammer since 5th edition and I think that, of all of these iterations, 6th was indeed the best, but there are a lot if things I like about the current edition, as well: The horde formations and extra ranks getting to fight; combats seem to have more back-and-forth interaction and last a little longer (maybe too long?); the way troop types and special rules are classified; and the overall core rules are pretty solid.
There are a handful of things I'd change, as well: bringing skirmishers back to the loose, 360-degree lone-of-sight formation; removing the Steadfast rule (part of the reason combats go on too long); rearranging the psychology rules so they have a little more of an impact (particularly Fear, which went from automatically breaking units to being a non-rule that gets forgotten most of the time); making war machines a little easier to kill with shooting; and– oh yeah– Magic.
I have what I think is a balanced, playable, and simple solution to the magic rules. If magic in 9th ends up being as broken as everyone fears, maybe I'll even push for my gaming group to use these rules instead. My take on magic is based on a combination of 6th edition and 8th edition, as each has some rules that I like.
Magic in 6th Edition Warhammer
This had the most elegant and simple set of magic rules. Most importantly, it was reliable, with a number of power dice based on the army you brought rather than a random roll to determine the strength of the winds of magic.
Power Dice Pool:2 dice. Each casting Wizard adds +1 per level (ie: level 1 adds 1 die, level 4 adds for dice). Dispel Dice Pool: 2 dice (4 dice for Dwarfs). Each dispelling Wizard of level 1 & 2 add 1 dice, level 3 & 4 Wizards each ass 2 dice.
Example: an army with a level 3 Wizard, a level 1, and a level 2 would consistently generate 8 power dice each turn, fewer if any Wizards get killed. The larger the army and the more Wizards it has, the more power dice it generates, allowing the amount of power dice in the casting and dispel pools to scale with the size of the game.
Casting:Wizards can roll a number of power dice up to their Wizard level +1 (ie: level 2 can roll up to 3 dice.) The roll needs to equal or exceed the casting value of the spell. Dispelling: The dispelling Wizard can roll any number of dispel dice. The dispel attempt needs to equal or exceed the casting roll to dispel the spell.
Irresistible Force:If two 6s come up in the casting roll, the spell automatically succeeds and cannot be dispelled. Miscasts:If two 1s come up in the casting roll, the spell is miscast and fails (regardless of the total). Dispelling:Double sixes and double ones in the dispel roll count as automatic success or failure, respectively.
Spells:Spells are generated randomly and multiple wizards could potentially have the same spell. Each wizard could cast attempt to cast each of his spells once as long as he has enough power dice to do so.
Bound Spells: These are cast automatically without the expenditure of power dice at the power level of the item. (ie: a bound spell (5) would be cast at the difficulty 5 and that's also the difficulty to beat when dispelling.
Magic in 8th Edition Warhammer
8th Edition is all about the dice rolls. Dice rolls for everything: Random roll for charge distance, random roll for the winds of magic, random roll to see it any of your Wizards can add to the power pool...you get the idea. All those rolls slow the game down and, more often than not, don't amount to any appreciable effect.
Power Dice Pool:The number of power dice is the result of a 2D6 "winds of magic" roll. Each casting Wizard channels +1 dice on a D6 roll of 6 (regardless of level) up to a total limit of 12 Dispel Dice Pool:The number of dispel dice is equal to the higher dice in the winds of magic roll. Each dispelling Wizard channels +1 dice on a D6 roll of 6 (regardless of level).
So, right off the bat, this system requires a roll, and then another roll to determine the number of power dice. The average would be 7, but can range from 2 to 12, resulting in an overpowered magic phase or a completely ineffective one. Wizards have a 1-in-6 chance to add extra dice, which usually results in zero dice. This system doesn't scale at all; a 5000 point game with six Wizards per side still generates an average of 7 power dice +1 for the channeling roll. Not nearly enough for the amount of wizards in play.
Casting: A Wizard can roll up to 6 power dice and add his level to the roll. The total needs to equal or exceed the casting value of the spell. Dispelling: The dispelling Wizard can roll any number of dispel dice and adds his level to the roll. The dispel attempt needs to equal or exceed the casting total to dispel the spell.
Irresistible Force/ Miscast: If two 6s come up in the casting roll, the spell automatically succeeds cannot be dispelled, and it is also miscast, requiring a roll on the miscast table once the spell's effects are resolved. Dispelling: Double sixes in the dispel roll count as automatic success.
Spells: Spells are generated randomly but any given spell (other than signature spells) can only appear once in the army. Each wizard could cast attempt to cast each of his spells once as long as he has enough power dice to do so.
The rule about not having duplicate spells also doesn't scale well because in larger games with multiple wizards, you quickly run out of spells in your chosen lore.
Bound Spells:These require power dice to cast, and the level of the item is the casting difficulty.
In 6th edition, bound spell items were the ace up your sleeve, used to either draw out your opponent's dispel dice early in the phase, or saved until the end to surprise your opponent after he used all his dice. It was a nice tactic that's lost in 8th edition. Having to spend power dice on bound items means those dice are taken away from your other spells. As the dispelling player, you know that once your opponent is out of dice, he's got nothing left. There's no "unseen threat."
Minimum 3 to Cast/ Not Enough Power: In 6th edition, the dice roll needed to equal at least 3 (before any bonuses) for the spell to succeed. This was fine because the lowest casting value was about 5, so you would be rolling two dice anyway. Less than 3 on two dice is double ones, which is a miscast anyway. In 8th edition there's a holdover of this rule requiring the dice roll to be at least 3. The problem is that now Wizards add their level to the roll, so a level 4 Wizard casting a spell with a difficulty of 6 really only needs to throw one dice at it to make the total. It's just a way of eating up power dice in a already fickle magic phase.
Furthermore, if a Wizard fails an attempt to cast or dispel, his concentration is broken and he can't make another attempt that magic phase. So that's another rule encouraging you to throw more dice than necessary at a spell to ensure your Wizard doesn't become useless because of an unlucky roll.
Magic in the End Times Warhammer: Khaine added new rules that further complicate things with even more random rolls and radically alter the way the Magic phase functions. I've been involved in a lot of the discussion over on the VampireCounts.net forums, a regular haunt of mine. ("Haunt!" get it?) I don't believe I've seen anyone say a single positive thing about the new magic rules. Power Dice Pool:The number of power dice is the result of a 4D6 "winds of magic" roll. Dispel Dice Pool:The number of dispel dice is equal to the highest 2 dice in the winds of magic roll. Casting and dispelling Wizards channel the same: +1 dice on a D6 roll of 6.
That's more dice for the magic phase, which is good. Even a below average winds of magic roll will still allow you to do something.
Casting: After choosing the Wizard, his spell, and nominating the target, the wizard must roll a D6, the result of which is how many power dice he can roll. Dispelling: Dispelling Wizards also roll a D6 to determine how many dispel dice they can use.
Irresistible Force/ Miscast:These function the same. Broken Concentration: Wizards can continue to cast spells if they fail a casting attempt.
Now we're adding two more rolls to the casting of each spell. (Literally, the casting Wizard rolls to see how many dice he can roll, then rolls those dice, and the dispelling Wizard rolls to see how many he can roll, and then he rolls his dice!) On top of that, you determine how many dice you get to roll after you've selected the spell to cast. This bit of randomness tones down the larger, unit-erasing spells because you can't just throw six dice at them hoping for irresistible force, but it makes it unreliable whether you'll have enough dice to roll for even a moderately difficult spell, or for your dispel attempt.
Spells:Spells are no longer generated randomly; Wizards know every spell in their chosen lore(s) and spells can be recast as long as a previous casting attempt wasn't failed and as long as the casting value isn't 15+ or greater. There are also "End Times" spells, which can only be cast once per phase and , if cast successfully, cannot be dispelled at all.
I haven't played a game with the End Times magic yet, and I do want to give it a try. I don't have high hopes because I already don't care for the randomness of the magic phase, and the End Times seems like it's even more random. People who have played say that the magic phase takes even longer, with all the rolls and wizards now having the entire library of spells to flip through when deciding what to cast. The general concern online is that these magic rules are a preview of what is to come in 9th edition. That's something I'm not looking forward to if it turns out to be the case.
My Ideal Magic Rules
Here's what I propose for a magic system that embraces the simplicity of 6th edition and addresses some of the power concerns. These rules are based on the 8th edition Warhammer core rules, spell lists and army books.
Power Dice Pool: 2 dice. Each casting Wizard adds +1 per level (ie: level 1 adds 1 die, level 4 adds for dice). Dispel Dice Pool: 2 dice (4 dice for Dwarfs) Each dispelling Wizard of level 1 & 2 add 1 dice, level 3 & 4 Wizards each ass 2 dice. (Dwarfs have their own rules for generating extra dice, I believe. If the current system allows their Runesmiths to channel dice, I'd say roll that back to the Runesmiths generating dice like they did in 6th edition.)
The way 6th edition generated dice was fine. No random rolls to slow things down and it's consistent from turn to turn. I thought about making the base dice 1 per full 1000 points, It works out to be normal in a 2000-3000 point game, but it gets out of control at higher point values. having more wizards adding dice to the pool takes care of the scaling. The casting difficulties of the 8th edition spells are considerably higher, so loading up on wizards for more dice doesn't necessarily mean more spells will be cast, just that the amount of dice at your disposal will be consistent. You'll still be rolling more dice per spell than you were in 6th.
Casting: A Wizard can roll a number of power dice up to his Wizard level +1 (ie: level 2 can roll up to 3 dice.) and add his level to the roll. The roll needs to equal or exceed the casting value of the spell. Dispelling: The dispelling Wizard can roll any number of dispel dice and adds his level to the roll. The dispel attempt needs to equal or exceed the casting roll to dispel the spell.
The casting difficulty of all the 8th edition spells are rather high because they assume that the Wizard's level will be added to the casting attempt, so we need to keep that rule. The rules for Broken Concentration and Not Enough Power are gone, so high level Wizards can cast low-difficulty spells more easily, and without fear of sitting out the rest of the phase if they fail their casting attempt.
Irresistible Force: If two 6s come up in the casting roll, the spell automatically succeeds and cannot be dispelled. Miscasts: If two 1s come up in the casting roll, the spell is miscast and fails (regardless of the total).
Dispelling: Double sixes and double ones in the dispel roll count as automatic success or failure, respectively.
I preferred irresistible force and miscasting as two separate things, rather than a single "catastrophic success."
Spells: Spells are generated randomly and multiple wizards can potentially have the same spell. Each wizard can attempt to cast each of his spells once per magic phase as long as he has enough power dice to do so.
That's a nice balance, I think, allowing the same spell to occur more than once per magic phase, without it being cast over and over. Fewer spells in each Wizard's inventory means less time spent deciding what you are going to cast each turn.
Bound Spells: These are cast automatically without the expenditure of power dice at the power level of the item. The bound spell's level is also the difficulty to beat when dispelling.
That's a return to the way it was in 6th Edition. I know that the levels and points cost of the bound items probably reflects the fact that you're expected to use dice on them, but that's fine. It's equal across the armies and not such a difference that it would cause an imbalance.
So, what does everyone think? Let me know in the comments. I realize the 9th edition rules are probably in the can already (and GW doesn't "take notes" as far as I know) so it's not like this would change anything. I mainly wanted to get this down so I can reference it later if things do take a turn for the worst and we need to start house ruling things.